The Flaming Fish Menu
The The Flaming Fish Menu brings a seafood-focused dining experience to 535 Main St, Buffalo, NY, with a selection that highlights fresh flavors and satisfying comfort dishes. The menu offers a variety of seafood favorites, featuring flavorful fish preparations, hearty plates, and options that showcase simple ingredients with bold seasoning. Alongside seafood choices, guests can enjoy complementary sides and well-balanced meals that make it easy to find something for lunch, dinner, or a casual gathering. The dishes are presented with a focus on taste, texture, and generous portions, creating an inviting choice for seafood lovers. Whether stopping by for a quick bite or a relaxed meal, the menu provides a welcoming mix of familiar favorites and flavorful creations.
1 / 4
SHAREABLES
FRIED GREEN TOMATOES
Fresh green tomatoes, perfectly fried to golden-brown perfection. Topped with our signature sauce.
SEAFOOD FRIES
Crispy seasoned fries smothered in melted cheese and crowned with a seafood medley. Drizzled with ur signature sauces and finished with fresh pico de gallo, shredded cheese and sour cream.
CRISPY CALAMARI
Crispy fried calamari rings served with creamy savory dipping sauce.
SEAFOOD CHEESE DIP
A creamy blend of cheeses loaded with shrimp, crab, crawfish tails, peppers, onions, spinach, and sweet corn. Served with fresh crispy fried chips. *Available for Dine In only*
CRISPY MOZZARELLA
Golden, crunchy perfection on the outside, warm gooey mozzarella on the inside. Served with marinara.
QUESADILLAS
A 12' tortilla toasted to perfection and filled with a blend of cheeses, sautéed bell pepper and onions, corn & beans and signature sauce with choice of protein.
BOMBAY SHRIMP
A pile of our specially seasoned fried shrimp tossed in our original Bombay sauce served on top of a bed of lettuce and topped with shredded carrots, red cabbage and green onions.
CUP & LEAF
GUMBO
Featuring tender chicken, succulent shrimp, and smoked beef sausage in a slow cooked rich broth.
HOUSE SALAD
A blend of mixed greens, juicy tomatoes, crisp carrots, tangy banana peppers, shredded cheese, and red onion topped with crunchy croutons. Served with dressing of choice.
CAESAR SALAD
Crisp romaine lettuce, grated parmesan cheese, and crunchy garlic croutons, served with a side of creamy caesar dressing.
STRAWBERRY SALAD
A blend of mixed greens, red onions, mandarin oranges, tangy feta cheese, sweet strawberries, and crunchy pecans. Served with raspberry vinaigrette.
THE MAINS
THE REMINGTON
7oz herb - crusted salmon paired with grilled shrimp, served over a bed of creamy garlic mashed potatoes and served with collard greens. Finished with our signature Sauce Remington.
THE BELTWAY
Grilled tilapia topped with succulent grilled shrimp and topped with our signature Sauce Remington. Served alongside our red beans & rice.
SKIPPERS HERB CRUSTED DINNER
Herb crusted butterfly trout, perfectly seasoned and served over a bed of creamy garlic mashed potatoes. Paired with char-grilled asparagus.
THE CRAB SHACK
Two golden, 4 oz house made crab cakes served alongside creamy garlic mashed potatoes and char-grilled asparagus. Finished with our signature Sauce Remington.
JAMBALAYA
Our take on a creole classic featuring savory rice loaded with onions, peppers, and celery. Tossed with tender chicken, juicy shrimp, and smoked beef sausage.
THE LEXINGTON
Grilled haddock paired with succulent grilled shrimp, served with cajun rice and char-grilled broccoli. Finished with a creamy spinach parmesan sauce.
THE MAIDEN VOYAGE
Crab cake stuffed salmon, succulent shrimp, and a tender lobster tail. Served over creamy garlic mashed potatoes, accompanied by collard greens. Finished with our signature Sauce Remington. A dish fit for a true seafood lover.
PASTA
PASTA LOUIE
Fettuccine past smothered in a rich creamy Alfredo sauce with spinach, perfectly seasoned. Topped with grilled salmon for a bold flavorful twist on a classic favorite.
CREAMY CAJUN PASTA
Fettuccine pasta tossed in our bold cadien cream sauce, featuring grilled salmon, smoked beef sausage, sautéed onions, peppers, and mushrooms. A deliciously spicy and creamy dish that's sure to satisfy.
MAGNOLIA SEAFOOD
A mouthwatering medley of shrimp, crawfish tails, mussels, lump crab and lobster claw, sautéed with bell peppers and onions. All tossed in a rich, creamy scampi sauce. Served over fettuccine pasta for a dish that's full of seafood goodness.
TACOS
THE FIESTA TACO
Fried or grilled tilapia topped with crisp lettuce, corn salsa, shredded cheese and drizzled with our signature sauce.
THE BAHAMA MAMA
Fried or grilled tilapia topped with crisp lettuce, pico de gallo and drizzled with our mild signature sauce.
THE SEABREEZE TACO
Fried or grilled tilapia topped with crisp lettuce, mango salsa and drizzled with our mild signature sauce.
Haddock All-In Taco
Fried Flatbread layered with our specially seasoned Haddock, French fries, Coleslaw and our species hot sauce
SANDWICHES
THE CLASSIC FISH SANDWICH
Crispy fried haddock, shredded lettuce, tomato, red onion, melted American cheese served on a toasted roll.
THE FISH HOAGIE
Crispy fried haddock with sautéed onions and peppers, melted American cheese, and drizzled with our signature sauce.
THE CRAB ATTACK
Two crab cake sliders topped with grilled shrimp, crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, melted American cheese and our signature sauce.
FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH
Crispy fried chicken breast topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, melted American cheese and our signature sauce.
THE SHRIMP PO'BOY
Crispy shrimp piled on a toasted roll, topped with lettuce, tomato, shredded cheese and drizzled with our special sauce.
THE PORTSIDE
Succulent lobster tossed in our magnolia sauce and a blend of cheeses, grilled to perfection between 2 slices of sourdough bread.
CAJUN SALMON SLIDERS
two grilled sliders served on soft buns with crisp lettuce, juicy tomato, red onion, and our signature sauce.
FRIED SEAFOOD
THE FISH FRY
Crispy fried haddock, perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices and fried to a golden perfection. Served with two house-made sides of your choice and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin.
THE SHRIMP FRY
10 crispy, golden-fried shrimp, perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices. Served with your choice of two house-made sides crafted fresh daily and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked in house.
THE FISH & SHRIMP COMBO
Crispy fried haddock, paired with golden-fried shrimp, both seasoned with our signature blend of spices. Served with two house-made sides crafted fresh daily, and with a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked fresh in house.
THE CAPTAINS COMBO
Crispy fried haddock, 10 shrimp, and calamari perfectly seasoned with our signature blend of spices and fried to golden perfection. Served with a flavorful house-made crab cake, 2 sides, and a jalapeño cheddar corn muffin- baked in house.
KIDS MENU
KIDS FRIED FISH & FRIES
KIDS FRIED SHRIMP & FRIES
KIDS CHEESE QUESADILLA & FRIES
KIDS CHICKEN QUESADILLA & FRIES
KIDS MINI CHEESE BURGERS & FRIES
KIDS CHICKEN STRIPS & FRIES
SIDES
FRENCH FRIES
COLESLAW
HUSHPUPPIES
COLLARD GREENS
GARLIC MASHED POTATOES
RED BEANS & RICE
BROCCOLI
CANDIED YAMS
BAKED MACARONI & CHEESE
CAJUN RICE
ASPARAGUS
FRIED OKRA
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 716-322-5480